What Is a Player to Be Named Later? MLB’s Strangest Trade Piece

by

“…and a player to be named later.” Baseball’s most familiar trade footnote is a real, rule-bound mechanism: a debt of one player, payable within six months, usually chosen from a list agreed the day of the deal – and settleable in cash if no name works out.

It exists because baseball’s calendar creates players who can’t legally be traded yet, deadlines that arrive before scouting is done, and value gaps too small to hold up a deal. And twice in history, it has produced the sport’s perfect absurdity: a player traded for himself.

MLB ROSTER RULES
Player to Be Named Later
The six-month IOU written into baseball’s trade rules
THE WINDOW
6 months
The deadline to name the player
THE MECHANISM
An agreed list
The receiving club usually picks from pre-set names
THE ESCAPE HATCH
Cash instead
Clubs can settle the debt with money
THE LEGEND
Traded for himself
It has happened – twice
How a PTBNL works
The rules behind the placeholder
Rule Detail
The six-month clock The player must be named within six months of the trade – miss it and the clubs settle in cash
The list mechanism Typically the clubs agree at the trade on a small list of eligible players; the receiving club scouts them and chooses within the window
Cash substitution The deal can close with money instead of a name – “cash considerations” is often a PTBNL that resolved quietly
Why not just name him now? Timing rules: recently drafted players can’t be traded immediately, and roster or waiver complications sometimes make “later” the only legal option
The evaluation angle The window doubles as a scouting period – the receiving club gets months of minor league looks before committing
Why clubs use it
The placeholder’s real jobs
Use case Example logic
Trading players who can’t be traded yet New draftees face a waiting period before they’re trade-eligible – a PTBNL bridges the gap legally
Deadline-day time pressure When July 31 arrives before scouting finishes, clubs agree on the list and sort the name out in August
Balancing a deal later A small gap in value gets papered over with “a PTBNL or cash” – flexibility both sides accept
The famous absurdity Harry Chiti (1962) and Dickey Noles (1987) were each sent back as the player named later in their own trades – traded for themselves
PTBNL FACTS
Watch the minor league box scores
The listed names usually aren’t public – but a receiving club’s scouts showing up at an affiliate for weeks is the tell.
“Cash considerations” has a story
Many cash-settled deals started as PTBNL lists where nobody impressed – the money is the residue of a failed audition.
The window has teeth
Six months is a hard deadline: clubs have eaten weaker names or settled cheap because the clock ran out.

The Mechanics of “Later”

At the trade, the clubs typically agree on a short list of eligible minor leaguers. The receiving club then has up to six months to scout the names and choose – or take cash instead. The window is a genuine evaluation period: months of affiliate looks the club wouldn’t get in a normal deadline scramble. Around the trade deadline, PTBNLs multiply for exactly this reason – the clock forces deals closed before the homework is done, and the placeholder buys time legally.

Why the Rules Create It

The deepest reason PTBNLs exist is that some players simply can’t be traded when the deal happens: recently signed draftees face a waiting period, and roster or waivers complications can make an immediate transfer impossible. Naming them “later” – after the restriction lifts – keeps the deal legal. The mechanism’s hall of fame: Harry Chiti in 1962 and Dickey Noles in 1987, each returned to complete the very trade that sent them out. The 40-man roster implications wait until the name is finalized – a PTBNL costs no roster spot until he’s actually named.

Quick Answers

Can a PTBNL be a major leaguer?

Almost never in practice – the mechanism lives in the minors, where roster restrictions don’t immediately bite and evaluation windows matter.

Do fans ever learn the list?

Rarely at the time – the names surface later through reporting, or never, when cash closes the deal instead.

Is there always a list?

No – some deals leave it fully open, though the agreed-list structure dominates because both sides prefer bounded risk.

The Bottom Line

A PTBNL is a six-month IOU with a scouting period attached: pick from the list, or pay cash when the clock runs out. It’s the flexibility valve baseball’s trade rules require – and occasionally, the punchline that sends a man across the country to be exchanged for himself.